Site Menu:
This is an archived Horseadvice.com Discussion. The parent article and menus are available on the navigation menu below: |
HorseAdvice.com » Treatments and Medications for Horses » Alternative or Herbal Medicatons » |
Discussion on Has Anyone Ever Tried Heiro? | |
Author | Message |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 11:56 am: During my extensive research on insulin resistance in horses, I came across this product and have been wondering if anyone has ever tried it. https://www.equinemedsurg.com/faqir.htmlThe write-up on it says that it was developed as a way to help IR horses maintain a more normal insulin level, while also being able to get them out of "dry lot jail" and out in pasture where they really want to be. It looks like a very interesting product, also helps normal easy keepers get out of jail as well. I'm really curious if anyone has used it and what their results were, good or bad.....I want to try it but, I'm skert. The price isn't bad either, much less than what I had to give my Cushing's horse for 5 years 11 months. If you have tried it, please share with me what you thought of it, or any comments you might care to share. |
Member: scooter |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 1:51 pm: Hi Patty, I never tried the supplement (surprisingly)because on my quest to release Hank from "jail" I would have tried anything.I hate to preach this but I have learned the hard way and try to save people time and money. Supplements aren't going to get horses out of "IR jail" ( MIGHT HELP)..Diet and exercise will. These kind of advertisements always lured me in for the quick cure, but let's face it if it was that good it would be one of the most popular supplements out there! Good bye grazing muzzles Tablespoon of supplement and horse can graze would be great!!!! These kind of advertisements make me mad now. Unknowing horse owners looking for a quick cure, could damage their horse for life with founder. Insulin levels vary day to day and if you recall me saying Hank didn't test IR on the day he was tested...OH but he is, no doubt in my mind at all!!! I would bet money if I put him on that supplement and out on some nice green grass he would be four feet in the air with the pain of founder. However when he went into spring with a BCS of 4-5 we had no problems. I know you wanted to know about the supplement, but I'm trying to save you some money and tell you I don't think there is one out there that beats the cheap choice of diet and as much exercise as possible. It's hard but possible, I battle it daily in my head. |
Member: scooter |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 2:46 pm: Patty I just read most of that website and it does have VERY good info in it. I still think IR can be be controlled just as well without the supplement. They seem to suggest diet and exercise as the way to go and ALSO use the supplement. The 1st page seems to insinuate with just the supplement you can have a "normal" horse, that's what I didn't like. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 7:31 pm: Thanks for your input Diane, I really value your opinion.I'd love to have contact with someone who has used it for an unbiased opinion...as in has nothing to gain or lose by sharing their experience. My fingers are crossed that someone here has used it as the website does make it sound really good.....but. I'm trying a slightly new approach with Ziggy and his feeding schedule. My usual grooming time is while he's eating his bedtime hay and I've noticed lately the colder it is, the ornerier he is....and the thought occurred to me that he may be "protecting" his hay in his mind. The change I made while it's cold out is to add hay to the 5:00 feeding so he's not quite so "starved" when I go back out at 9:30. I remember several saying that free choice hay made their horses calmer. Free choice is out of the question for him but maybe if I feed less hay in the morning, some hay at 5:00, then normal 2 lb. pad of hay for the night, I might find him not so up tight and starving at 9:30. It ends up being a slight increase in hay but when it's in the 20's to 50's, I don't think it will hurt him any. You mentioned again that Hank tested negative for IR but you swear he is? I'm in the same boat and refer to you when anyone looks at me like I have a wet noodle in my brain. The crest, the starvation stories he tells my visitors....yup, that's him, a perfect example of a closet IR...lol. Which reminds me---->how are the round bales working for Hank's weight? Today we put in a 70 gallon water tub with screw in heating element...to replace my heated stall buckets. Ziggy, in his infinite wisdom, entertains himself by banging the heated buckets (lift and let go) into the wall and sooner rather than later, they no longer work. He's broken 2 out of 3 sooooo, to outsmart him, the 70 gallon is too big for him move. This may also help with my other problem as well---> Bokay won't drink out of an indoor bucket but she would drink out of an ice bucket outside. I'm hoping the heated tub will encourage her to drink since it's outside and not covered with ice in the morning...or so it's supposed to work that way. My other project today...now don't laugh...we had to put a rescue net behind the stall wall in Ziggy's stall...to catch chickens when they drink too much and fall off their roost. There's a 4 inch gap between the 2x4's and the outer wall and for some God foresaken reason, 12 chickens have moved into the barn and perch on the top of his back wall...lol. One was missing for a day or two and I found her behind the wall patiently waiting to be rescued (with a fishing net). Now the space is filled with a wire net...that way they can't fall down but their ummmmmm business can? There's a henhouse and various coops so why they moved into the barn is a mystery but, there they are, 12 of them. They're mostly banties, leaving the bigger ones in the other areas. AS I often say....never a dull moment. To finish out the holiday decor, I had bought a pappa deer, momma deer and a baby dear for out front....today they came out of their boxes and appear to be enjoying my front yard. Heck, they were on sale, I couldn't resist. OK, back to original question: Has anyone here ever tried Heiro? I'm really curious to know how well it worked................ |
Member: ekaufman |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 8:33 pm: Hi Patty,I know you weren't looking for my opinion, but you can easily skip the rest of this. You seem very nice, but maybe still looking for a shortcut with a horse who needs a different program. The heiro web page is quite weaselly-- they invoke the labs that performed the bloodtests, implying that their claims for the supplement have been clinically proven, but I see no actual research attributed to those labs or to anyone else. It's like me invoking CSU's blessing because I use their diagnostic lab. Possibly I missed something. Vitamin E has been suggested for research into neurological/inflammatory research, but I don't find studies here or elsewhere suggesting it's got useful properties for IR. If supplements let fat mammals live like normal mammals without diet or exercise, and without making them sick well, heck, the rest of that thought is obvious. The horse (and human) body is an absolutely fair system-- if the body uses what it consumes, it stays fit; if it consumes more than it uses, it gets fat. IR is really just a re-statement of that second clause. Some burn more efficiently than others, but every horse has an internal logic. So your horse is fat-- he does NOT need to consume more, even a teaspoon. He needs to consume less or use more, even though that is very inconvenient for you. I have a neighbor with 20 acres and 2 little POA mares + foal who live 24x7x365 in a 20'x20' enclosure. The mares banged their feed buckets constantly, so the woman bought a tractor-tire feeder, and now the stronger of the 2 bangs that up and down. Out here, people call them "the prisoners" and figure she's just rattling her cup against the bars. Your 5 year-old can't write you a note or read to amuse himself-- his behavior is telling you that he needs more than a heavier tank or money in supplements. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 9:26 pm: Elizabeth......of course I was looking for your opinion...I'm hoping more will chime in.The write-up comes across as the miracle every IR horse wants but my emotional involvement makes me want to hear from someone who has used it. I've been giving Zig more lunge time as best I can until after the holiday. By the time Christmas is here, I have to take a week off just to recover..by spending the first two days flat on my back refusing to move, unless someone yells FIRE! Truth be known, I would pay any reasonable price to get Zigman out in the pasture, if it's out there and really works, I'll buy it. At this point, I don't think there's a routine he and I are built for that would make him able to hit the pasture all day....and that leaves me vulnerable to adds like this one. If I knew someone it worked for, I'd be willing to try it............ Ziggy has a very active mind that I think is tied in with his very high IQ. Keeping him entertained is a challenge, he has hula hoops, jugs of rocks and until he flattens it, a great big kid's ball. Sometimes I leave buckets out just to see where they'll end up by morning...lol. He's definitely not one for just standing around with that "duh" look on his face, his head is always up and watching everything. I've never seen such a busy mind. If he were a person, you'd never find him watching tv, he'd be out in the garage tinkering or taking something apart to see how it works...lol. Anyway, I truly am interested in what everyone thinks of the link...good or bad.....honest. |
Member: ekaufman |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 9:34 pm: Hi Patty,SO why not strap a grazing muzzle on him (I know they commonly take some tweaking) and turn him out? I have had only one bad experience with one-- a filly who decided it made a nifty weapon and began beating horses and other people about the head with it... until the boss showed up. I know several founder-prone horses locally who are turned out in grazing muzzles, and it's better than the alternatives (locked up, or blown up). - elk |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Sunday, Dec 14, 2008 - 11:11 pm: Hi Elizabeth.I've considered using one but will have to shop around to find one that will fit his little Arab nose. My Cushing's horse had one but she figured out how to maneuver it and eat thru the webbing, rather than the little hole in the end of it. Once she started doing that, it became a mute point and I just cut back on the grazing time. My concern would be he would figure out the same thing...which would not at all surprise me. But it is worth considering, at least once the Spring grass comes along. |
Member: scooter |
Posted on Monday, Dec 15, 2008 - 6:08 am: Patty I don't know what the weather is like in VA. in the winter, but last year I had to throw the diet out the window after we turned cold. They all got VERY cranky on the diet. This winter is starting the same and our cold/windchills (this morning it's -29)the horses really needed more hay.If your temps are 20-50 degrees as stated above....well mine seem to thrive in that. I have/had a real hard time dieting them in the winter and actually went to pretty much free choice last year when temps were zero or below. -20 -60 degree wind chills were quite common and that stupid weather bug chirped warnings daily...just like today (winter storm watch, wind chill advisory today) after it was 50 degrees and raining yesterday afternoon. The horses got wet and I hope they aren't out there froze this morning in -20 windchill I guess my point is everyones situation is different as I think Dr.O. stated in my big bale thread. Hank IS IR, Hank is a hog, and Hank foundered a couple times due to my mismanagement. The one thing that helped me most was Hanks Weight Watchers Diet Thread, amazingly the help and ideas I got, but mostly the moral support helped more than anything. There are a lot of people with fat horses that live on air. The weekly pictures and weighing kept me in line. Hank was pretty much starved until he hit HIS ideal weight, with a little management and exercise he was able to graze this year all year mostly (limited in spring) Just cutting his pasture in half and letting them eat it down slowly let him be out and moving instead of locked up. I still struggle daily with this, and once in awhile throw out a cry for help here. It sounds so easy but it's not! Maybe if you started a thread and included EVERYTHING Ziggy gets to eat Dr.O. could help you tweak his diet. IF he is loosing weight now and cranky don't worry about it they get over it, Cranky is much better than founder...believe me. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Monday, Dec 15, 2008 - 10:13 am: Good morning...and thanks for commenting Diane.I'm in a bit of a rush this morning (late again) but I wanted to share this little tidbit: Last night when I fed for the night, Ziggy was an absolute dream, calm, quiet, very gentle towards his momma. He was so mellow and sweet that I even mentioned it to hubby when he came out a little later. I was sooo floored, I even asked Ziggy why he was in such a good mood. The weather was a little warmer but all I did last night was pick feet and brush manes...but even that, he was perfect. Totally stumped, I just said "thank you for being such a good boy tonight." Little did I know--------> When hubby fed at 5:00 (while I hosed down the haynets), he closed the pasture gate BUT, he forgot to close the back door to the other barn....and guess what direction Ziggy came from when I fed at 9:30? YUP. Sometime after he would have been done with his 5:00 haynet, he discovered the open door and went back out. I don't know if it was for maybe 1 hour or possibly 3 hours but much to my relief (due to the dead grass), he is fine both last night and this morning....... Now I find myself thinking back---->Why did his sneak attack on the pasture mellow him out so much? There was no aggression, no foul mood, no "protecting" his hay...he just acted normal, why? Could this be a clue to something? He has no flags to say ulcer (lack of appetite, loose stools, biting or stancing...but could it be? Is there an irritation going on that his stomach needs food to prevent? Dr.O, I hope you're reading this, my inquiring mind really wants to know. Diane...Virginia winters are nothing like yours but anything below 30 and we huddle by the fireplace. If I were to guess, anything below 40 seems to bring out the "feed me or I'll die" attitude. Maybe it's like yours but relative to what they're used to for an environment? Interesting............. Gotta run, I am my own worst boss....lol. |
Member: leslie1 |
Posted on Monday, Dec 15, 2008 - 10:52 am: Hey PattyBI havent tried the supplement, but what about instead of buying an expensive supplement why not use that money to offer to pay a 4-H'er to come out and exercise The Ziggster? maybe a little longeing along with some of the 7 games to keep his mind preoccupied. Cheers Leslie |
Moderator: DrO |
Posted on Monday, Dec 15, 2008 - 6:53 pm: I am a bit confused PattyB we started with herbal treatments for insulin resistance and now you are wondering why when a colt is turned out on pasture he might calm down a bit? Am I missing a connection here?Herbal therapy for insulin resistance is unlikely to have much effect. Yes some of these herbs, cinnamon for instance, has shown some activity but the clinical significance at these dosages is not known and very unlikely to be of benefit. As to turning out horses on pasture to calm them down, it is a time honored and well proven method. DrO |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Tuesday, Dec 16, 2008 - 9:42 am: Oops , my bad......I meant to post that under grumpy gelding test results...which I will go do right now.----------------------------------------- OK, I moved the post if you want to delete my misplaced one from yesterday (the 15th). |
New Member: shedwall |
Posted on Tuesday, Oct 6, 2009 - 10:57 am: Hi Patty. I have a 5 year old Paso Fino mare who is Insulin Resistant. She foundered twice with rotation both times. She is not on pasture as our property was burned during the Hayman fire and there are too many obstacles and potential hazards for my horses to be let out. Even without pasture - Ali has had problems. The first founder episode was written off to a virus by her veterinarian. By the second founder episode a complete endocrine test was performed and her Insulin levels were off the chart.All of her hay is now tested to find the lowest sugar/starch levels available. She is on Well Solve L/S and Beet Pulp - all snacks have been eliminated with the exception of dry roasted peanuts in the shell. I also started her on the Heiro supplement and her Insulin levels have DrOpped 25% since this began. (I can't say if this is the Heiro or feeding of hay which has been tested for low levels ... time will tell but I feel it is worth a try). We have also kept another founder episode at bay. I take her for walks everyday and she is turned out into an indoor arena with another of my horses to play. Ali is not your classic IR horse as she is not overweight - never has been - and she is very hard to keep weight on. I figured Heiro was worth a try as nothing else was working for her. I will be running another blood test at the end of October and am anxious to see if her Insulin is any lower. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Tuesday, Oct 6, 2009 - 2:22 pm: Hi Shelley....and thanks for posting.I'm very interested to know how your experiment goes, please keep me posted. It took almost a year to really understand what was going on with the Zigster but after allll the experimenting I did with him, it took a combination of the following to get rid of his mood swings that apparently were all connected with insulin responses. 1. Cut way back on pasture time but allow as much turn out time as possible in a sacrifice area. The most grazing time he can have, green grass or dead grass has been zeroed in on 3 hours. Now that he is of normal weight though, it will be interesting to see if the dead grass still sends him off the deep end this winter. 2. I did put him on Quiessence for the magnesium/chromium and so far, I have enough faith in my vet and the product that I have left him on it. 3. Feed a small amount of Triple Crown Lite feed to keep him up on his other vitamins and minerals....and protein. 4. Weigh his hay with a digital scale....not the mechanical one, (mine was not calibrated right). Once I got the hay right, he get's around 5 lbs. daily in addition to turn out grazing time, the weight came right off. I also soak his hay for an hour or more since there is no one around here that sells tested hay. 5. When he needs more calories to maintain his weight, I use Triple Crown Rice Bran Oil Plus. By using fat calories to help stabilize him, I have been able to keep his carb calories down. 5. I also use TC Safe Starch Forage to add bulk without adding a lot of carbs. By suing this approach, he had made tremendous progress in the mood swings....which came hand in hand with his "I'm starving" attitude. One of his insulin signals is the more grass or hay you fed, the hungrier he got. Right now, he is at the point where his appetite is perfectly normal, even walks away from some of his food and goes back to it later.....totally opposite from where we were a year ago. Keeping his IR under control takes a combination of all of the above. Because I don't ride much, I keep him loose in the paddock and arena as much as possible, then they get grass time for 3 hours, depending on the growth pattern. Everything I've done with him has been under the guidance of a vet with a PhD in equine nutrition so, I know it's all been done safely. He feels better, acts better and looks better....normal by most standards. I did try putting him out on mature grass but with the voracious appetite, he just ate a lot of grass which always set us backwards....darn it. It will be interesting to see how he does with the winter grass this year....... Anyway, please keep me/us posted on your experience with Heiro. It would be great if it works as stated but since I don't know anyone using it locally, I just don't know what to think. But good luck to you, I'll be waiting and wondering. |
New Member: shedwall |
Posted on Tuesday, Oct 6, 2009 - 6:46 pm: I will let you know the results. With Ali, I know that I am looking for a miracle. None of the changes that my vet and I have tried with her have worked to lower her Insulin to a safer level. I am grateful for any improvement that shows in her blood. With 2 rotations (total of 10% now) she just can't handle any more!One thing I have considered - Now that I started it - I probably would be terrified to stop - wondering if her Insulin will skyrocket again. Will keep you posted. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Wednesday, Oct 7, 2009 - 12:27 am: Thanks Shelley.I will admit, I was fortunate to find Ziggy's problem early before any damage was done. My initial clue that something was waaay off with him was the drastic mood swings....fine one day, nice and mellow...and attacking his food like he's starving the next day. I can't tell you how many nights I laid in bed staring at the ceiling wondering what was setting him off. When the specialist spent 15 minutes talking with me about him, as soon as I said voracious appetite, he knew right where to start. It was early enough in the process that his resting blood work was normal yet a few hours after grazing, he was like a raving lunatic by feeding time a few hours later. The difference in his attitude was actually shocking and I knew there had to be a cause. Once I started subtracting carbs, weighing and soaking his hay and adding fat for maintenance calories, he just turned right around within a week at the most. Good luck Shelley! |
Moderator: DrO |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 11:03 am: The status of the research on herbal treatment of insulin resistance is about the same as it was when I wrote the response above.Every time I go and review the HEIRO site I find it misleading in several ways. They try to associate their product with well recognized research institutions but a careful reading makes you realize that the association has nothing to do with testing or endorsing the efficacy of the product. The numbers they put up as examples of horses they have helped are way out of whack with what are the insulin values of IR values for properly tested horses and some may be in range of values of unfasted normal horses. For examples of these numbers see the graphs in the article Diseases of Horses » Endocrine System » Equine Metabolic SynDrOme and Insulin Resistance. We have just completed a major rewrite and update of this article. DrO |
Member: erika |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 11:39 am: Dr. O, I have heard similar critique of Heiro's website and practices. I also hear they have been a bit devious in their manipulation of insulin levels in order to report benefits. I personally would not buy from a company with a reputation such as theirs.Erika |
Member: shedwall |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 12:12 pm: Dr. O,Do you have any other ideas for Ali? Her insulin (according to her vet) tested at over 2500. Right now she has DrOpped to 1700. She is in a very dangerous position right now with 2 episodes of founder with rotation. I know there are new drugs from the pharmaceutical companies coming out - but they are still new. Glucose levels have DrOpped from 16.9 to 8.3. As you can tell - we have a long ways to go. She again is 5 years old. I have had her since the day she was born - here on the ranch. She is not fed any hay that is not tested, Purina Well Solve L/S, beet pulp, and peanuts in the shell or alfalfa cubes for a treat. I have a wonderful horseshoer (thank heavens) who builds custom shoes for her and has made her sound after these founder episodes. Any other ideas - she gets NO pasture, and Ali has NEVER been overweight. In fact - it is difficult to keep weight on her!!! Lots of exercise - turn out in arena with her friend, and I take her for walks every day. Please let me know any thoughts you might have. Shelley |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 12:17 pm: Wow, thanks for posting Dr.O and Erika.I will admit, there was a time when I was interested in trying it but what puzzles me to this day is that I never see articles about it in any of the horse magazines. My thoughts are that if it does show to be very effective, the miracle we all wish we had, it will start showing up in magazine articles or, perhaps a medical journal or two? But at the same time, since I've never used it, I can't say one way or the other if it works. I guess as with any of our experiments, go slow and be very observant/test often. |
Member: pattyb |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 12:30 pm: Yikes.....Shelley....you were posting while I was typing and I see now how tricky your situation is. I send you sincere best wishes that you can get her stabilized. I don't quite understand your numbers but your vet must have been using a different test yet I have to ask (Dr.O) if there is possibly also an early onset Cushing's involved? I know 5 is awfully early but it's a thought worth throwing on the table?Good luck Shelley! |
Member: scooter |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 5:21 pm: Shelley you do have a tough one.If you erase her insulin and glucose levels how is she doing otherwise? |
Member: shedwall |
Posted on Thursday, Oct 8, 2009 - 8:47 pm: Right now she is doing very well. Her coat is shiny, she's happy - outwardly appears healthy - although somewhat underweight. Since the last bout of founder and rotation - knock on wood - no lameness issues right now. |
Moderator: DrO |
Posted on Friday, Oct 9, 2009 - 7:23 am: Hello ShellyHI have moved this request for further information to your other post on this problem along with instructions on how to start your own discussion. DrO |